Choss Boys
  • Home
  • Theory
  • Guest Writings
  • About
  • Contact

Theory of Climbing

Climbing, as seen through the eyes of the Choss Boys

Watched pot never boils

7/6/2016

2 Comments

 
I (Erik) need a new way to boil water.

And I'm not alone! At campsites all over the world climbers are emerging from their tents and are hunching over Jetboils, PocketRockets, and even electric kettles waiting for their precious H2O to reach 100C.

There's no question that a morning brew is essential for an alpine start and that your instant oatmeal just isn't the same with cold water - but the question remains: what's the best way to boil the water? I went out and did some snooping.
Picture
For years I've used an MSR PocketRocket with a crappy aluminium pot perched on top. There's a couple of issues here:
  • It takes forever to boil.
  • It takes longer if there's a baby's breath of wind.
  • It is a precarious balancing act.

So there I am, wasting gas and staring at my slightly steaming water trying to will the whole thing to stay upright. Learning that a watched pot never boils. Enough is enough!

I went to the local outfitters store and made a list of what they had available. Below are the available integrated stove / canister systems with auto-ignition. All have hanging kit functionality (comes extra) which could be handy in a portaledge. But one is the winner.

MSR Windburner ($140)
The design relies on a radiant burner being better than a flame for boiling water, and a system for ensuring the thing stays lit in windy conditions.
1L capacity, boil time 4:30 per 1L, weighs 15.5 oz.


MSR Reactor ($220)
Essentially a bigger beefier older brother of the Windburner. There are two modes of heat transfer - convective and radiant - which is great if you're a stove nerd, I guess. (Stove nerds exist. I've met them.) So, this the Lamborghini of stoves.
1.7L capacity, boil time 3:00 per 1L, weighs 1 lb. 3 oz.


Jetboil Joule ($235)
Meant for large groups. Expensive.
2.5L capacity, boil time 2:40 per 1L, 1 lb. 9.2 oz. (heavy!)


Jetboil MiniMo ($145)
Seems to be a competitor to the MSR Windburner. Except it doesn't appear to be designed specifically for windy conditions.
1L capacity, boil time 4:30 per 1L, weighs 14 oz. (light!)


Jetboil Sumo ($156)
Perhaps a competitor to the MSR Reactor.
1.8L capacity, boil time 3:45 per 1L, weighs 1 lb

Jetboil Flash ($120)
This appears to be a classic. Pretty cool how there is a colour-change indicator. Although, steam and bubbles are a pretty indicator of boiling if you ask me.
1L capacity, boil time 4:30 per 1L, weighs 15.25 oz.


Jetboil Zip ($91)
Meant for solo trekkers who are probably ounce-counters. Probably not the best choice for car-camping climbers.
0.8L capacity, boil time 5:00 per 1L, weighs 11.75 oz. (very light!)


Overall, the MSR stoves appear to have a more powerful stove and better wind protection. Wind protection is a plus for me (it's windy in Newfoundland). Also, 1L capacity is plenty for me. According my math, 1L = 3 cups of coffee.

So let's see - one coffee per Gumbo, delivered in less than 5min, even in windy conditions... the winner is.. THE MSR WINDBURNER! ​
​

Picture

​- Erik
2 Comments
Leena-Mari Veitch link
7/15/2016 04:34:01 am

Paljon tietoa veden keitosta :D Sen voi lisätä, että vesi kiehuu, kun selän kääntää ;)

Reply
Ann Marie
7/15/2016 08:30:23 pm

Love the analysis! You seem to have some experience in comparison shopping. Great skill for life!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Camper Van
    Climbing Lifestyle
    Tales Of Climbing
    Training
    Travel

    Authors

    We are Daniel, David, Nick & Erik.
    We climb rocks.
    We come from St. John's, Newfoundland - the most Easterly city in North America. We are passionate about climbing, and want to share our adventures and misadventures with YOU.

    EMAIL UPDATES

    Keep up to date with our adventures! Subscribe below to get an email for each new blog post.

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Archives

    December 2018
    October 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    November 2017
    September 2017
    March 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Theory
  • Guest Writings
  • About
  • Contact